Wednesday, January 23, 2013

Monday, January 14, 2013

Instructions On How To Perform A Miracle

For your average modern Xn one of the most impressive things Jesus ever did where his miracles. Even Peter and John seemed to take up the mantle and performed a miracle or two. But today, although I've met a whole bunch a Xns, I still haven't seen a single miracle. It got me thinking why doesn't the New Testament give a single instruction on how to perform a miracle? Why doesn't Jesus say blessed are the miracle makers? Why doesn't he teach us how to pay a poor person's taxes by retrieving it from the mouth of a fish? Instead of this useful trick, we're told to sell everything and give the money to the poor. Instead of being told how to heal a beaten and dying man we're told the parable of the Good Samaritan and told to go and do the same.

Most of Jesus miracles got people who would have faced some exclusion from the temple into the temple. Peter and John's healing of a lame man occurred at the gate to the temple and got him in the temple. In to the temple and back in with the community of God. Maybe the biggest miracle was that Xns took the community of God, the kingdom of God, outside of the temple. Where, Jesus like so many of the Old Testament prophets had called it to be.   

The lack of instructions on how to perform miracles alongside the large number of miracles should be hard to ignore. Each miracle is evidence of the breaking in of the Kingdom of God, a time when the religious elite or the imperial elite no longer determines who’s in and who’s out or who can do what. It is a time when God is in charge. The challenge for us is not that we go on performing miracles but rather that we live as though God is in charge and not the government, the church, the economy or other social conventions. The challenge is not that we look after our own safety first but that we stop and look after an injured homeless man, Good Samaritan style. Or, the challenge is not that we horde money for ourselves for later but that we give to those in need. This I suspect is the challenge of the miracles, not that we change the world by performing them. But rather that we live as though God is in charge and that social, economic, religious and political rules and conventions do not apply.

Sunday, January 13, 2013

I Don't Believe In An Interventionist God... Sort Of

A little while ago I found myself in a room of Xns celebrating God's "intervention" in someone's life. An answered prayer for healing to be exact and then we were all praying together for God to intervene again in a similar way. I felt the urge to mumble the opening lines of Nick Caves "Into My Arms" - "I don't believe in an interventionist God. But I know, darling, that you do". Obviously it seemed a bit rude to do so at the time. If I'm honest, technicaly,  I probably do believe in an interventionist God, it's just not in the ussual, "God, stop the volcano errupting" or "God, find me a car park" kind of way. Essentially I believe that God can change me or someone else. If we're up for it, God can make us more like Christ, and that's about it.  

Despite growing up being encouraged to pray for God to intervene, I was never that confident that my moments of answered prayer were any greater than random chance. My "interventionist God" house of cards completely fell when I heard of an aid worker who spent the night at a village church in a foreign country where the whole village had turned out to sing praises to God and ask for protection from an approaching militia. He left late that night, early the next morning the whole village was slaughtered. I could no longer believe that my car parking spot could possibly be more important than the lives of these people.

I believe God's big intervention in the world was through a middle eastern labourer whose dad had been kicked out of his hometown. He worked hard to explain what God was like but by the time he was killed most of his followers had run away. One even turned him in to be killed. On the world stage it's a pretty small time intervention. Certainly, not one befitting a big powerful deity. It is in this spirit that I suspect God continues to act. Small time, changing people, slowly but none the less intervening. So I guess I do believe in an interventionist God just not in the spectacular interventionist way it's often talked about or prayed for.

Thursday, December 27, 2012

Help! I'm Caught In A Cult And I Can't Get Out

Sometimes it's hard to recognise that you are in a cult. That you are part of a group that dogmaticly holds to a set of beliefs no matter what the evidence around you is. My family, friends and extended community are all part of this cult so, when I stick my hand up and say I don't think the UFO is coming to rescue us, people stare at me like I'm an idiot.

The cult I'm in so pervasive that I don't even know what it's called. As far as I'm concerned this is how everybody lives and I'm starting to doubt some of our most foundational doctrines.

I no longer believe the following...

1) I no longer believe I gain pleasure or satisfaction through consumption. I no longer believe that a brown fizzy liquid will make my life better or that a shiny white phone will make me more connected with my friends and family. I longer believe that buying anything will make me happy. The most rewarding thing I did all year was give away a whole bunch of my stuff.

2) I no longer believe in eternal growth: I no longer believe that we can continue to use more and more of our infinite resources with no consequence least of all consequence that they might run out.

3) I no longer believe in moral progress: I'm no longer believe that we are morally superior to our fore-fathers. We may not have slaves serving us coffee and biscuits. Instead we slaves picking our coffee and chocolate for our biscuits. We haven't removed slavery or slave like conditions we have just removed it from our immediate view.

Then there's this certain level of unease that so many things I have learnt are only useful in the cult. For example: I can name twenty American Brand names but not one edible plant in my local area. I spent hours learning how to do quadratic equations as a teenager but i had no idea how to do an oil change on a car. It was like I was educated to live somewhere other than the reality I find myself in.  

I am an apostate and a renegade in this cult. I want to run away but I don't even know where the door to the compound is located.

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Thoughts On Christmas And The Island That Bears It's Name

In the Christmas narrative Mary and Joseph are without a home. When they wander back to the place that Joseph grew up (presumably his home until he was kicked out by the current Roman occupiers) things have been so utterly changed by the Roman Empire that there isn't even a set of relatives or old friends that he and his pregnant wife can seek lodging with. It looks like this is not an unfamiliar story either because all the lodging is taken all except a barn full of animals. Later to save Jesus life Joseph and Mary seek refuge in Egypt. Probably something they'd be reluctant to do given the history between their people and the Egyptians. Every Christmas we remember the family who fled from persecution, unable to stay in their hometown or surrounding country, seeking refuge in a strange place. It's perhaps fitting that the place in Australia where many people are doing that exact same thing all through the year is called Christmas Island.

Friday, December 14, 2012

Looking Beyond Scapegoats

Since the tragic suicide of the nurse involved in the 2day FM prank call media outlets, fuelled by regular readers and viewers, have been baying for blood. The prime targets have of course been the two DJs who made the prank call in the first place. As much the call was juvenile and intended to humiliate someone and the decision to air the call without permission is appalling (a decision I doubt the DJs in question would have personally made) their is a wider responsibility than just the two DJs.
 
Ever since the story emerged I have wondered how the nurses workplace superiors responded to the situation. I think most people have been in enough workplaces to know that some work superiors would take empathy with you and go into bat for you and others would blame you completely including possibly dismissing you from your job. It has been recently revealed that a suicide note is critical of the way that hospital staff responded to the prank call. Exactly what this criticism is, of course, I don't know

Then there is the culture around celebrity (including the royal family) that on the one hand we (collectively) demand that their private lives be private and on the other hand that we should know every detail about their private lives. Hence we send in the paparazzi to chase down celebrity to get every detail doing the dirty work for us being our scapegoat so we can enjoy the results of what they do whilst simultaneously being disgusted by them. Really, all the DJs were was paparazzi in disguise. Instead of hanging of window ledges and taking photos or tapping phones, they just got the information in a far more novel way. What drove the paparazzi to chase down Princess Diana is what drove 2Day FM to not only make the phone call put broadcast it without permission.

We need to take responsibility. This tragedy is not just the result of the sin of two DJs. There are greater systemic problems at play. The first of which we need to address is our desire to simplicity scapegoat someone. Whether that's a workplace scapegoating a single employee, media consumers scapegoating paparazzi, our scapegoating the two DJs, Or even more tragically a single person scapegoating themselves for something that was not their fault..

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

The Filthy Jesus Experiment Update And A Christmas Mini Sermon

As some of you may know or remember I've got a band together. I like playing music and I like Ye Olde Gospel type music so out came The Filthy Jesus Experiment. I've posted an introduction to the idea of the band here. I'm envisaging the band playing in pubs and like a ye olde revival meetings preaching a mini sermon or two during the songs. It's been a challenge to think of what I might say. The audience would be a regular pub going people probably expecting to be some kind of punk burlesque take on ye olde Christianity.

Here is what I came up with for a Christmas sermon.
As we move in to the craziness of the Christmas season. Many of us will not be celebrating happy families, content lives and rich presents. So, this season the The Filthy Jesus Experiment will not be celebrating that Christianity offers us some kind of tonic to make us happy, content and rich. Instead we will be celebrating that God has come to earth via an illegitimate family, amongst the poverty of an oppressed people and in the filth of an animal stable. No God did not give us a cleansing tonic to cure our ills, instead God gave us a Filthy Jesus.
If you want you can "like" the band on Facebook.

Saturday, December 08, 2012

Jesus Is The Centre Of My Faith. Or, Why I Should Stop Wasting My Time And Be More Like My Wife

Ask me if Jesus is the centre of my faith and I’ll say a resounding “yes!” If you observe my life you’ll see a different reality. In reality the Bible is often the centre of my faith. The Bible is what sermons get preached from, it’s what gets quoted to substantiate a position on almost everything apart which footy team I should to follow. If you come out of a more evangelical tradition like me, as long as someone could pull out a Bible verse or two to substantiate their position then there was no need to ask further questions. If, on the other hand, we ever heard someone say ‘Jesus was nice, so let’s do something that’s nice,’ we would recoil at what we perceived as a very wishy-washy theological basis for any idea or activity.

Of course things weren’t always as simple as quoting one proof text. Older texts could always be ‘trumped’ by newer ones. For example, if anyone ever suggested that we should adopt Old Testament purity laws. Then we could deliver an avalanche of counter ‘proof texts’ particularly from Paul. Not that this ever happened, but we were ready in case it did.

Now, my theology is far less evangelical than it used to be. If anyone asks me why I believe in gender equality, why I’m gay affirming, or why I believe that we should not repeat Ezra’s ethnic cleansing I can explain and, like a good evangelical, explain from the Bible. It might sometimes mean a bit of a theological workout, looking at the meaning of original Greek words and the context of the original passage, but we could get there.

On the other hand if anyone was to ask my wife these same questions she'd probably shrug her shoulders and say ‘ask Chris’. I suspect she just can’t be bothered with all my pharisaic like theological gymnastics just to get to a position to which she already knows in her heart to be true. She knows it to be true because she’s spent a life time trying to be like Jesus, rather than me who has spent a life time trying to wrestle with scripture. If we walk in the city she takes the cash. If I get asked by a homeless person for some money I need ten minutes to work out what the best thing to do is. She’ll just hand over the cash. She just has a more natural ability to embody Jesus than me. She spent the first twenty five years of her life listening to sermons on why it was important to submit to your husband and spent them single because she refused to date anyone who believed that. Despite what everyone else said she just knew that sort of dominate/subordinate relationship didn't line up with who Jesus was.

Recently, I heard a great talk explaining how the feeding of the 4000 parallels with Joshua’s conquest of Jericho. (It’s not as far-fetched as it sounds). Anyway, just as I was about to tell my wife about it, I realised she didn't need some convoluted explanation about why we shouldn’t kill thousands of innocent people and take their land from them. Of course, she wouldn’t even think that could ever be justified. All it took was for her to once read Jesus saying ‘you’ve heard it said, but I say...’ for her to know the right answer, the Jesus answer, is always the compassionate answer. As exciting as my theological discovery was I couldn't help but think maybe I should make Jesus the centre of my faith and not the Bible. Maybe I should stop wasting my time and be more like my wife.

---

This is article first appeared in the Anabaptist Association of Australia & New Zealand Journal "On The Road" (December 2012 Issue 54). Which I have to say I feel quite honoured about :-).

Friday, December 07, 2012

Why St Nicholas Would Slap Santa In The Face

Santa Claus is the modern day successor of St Nick. But to be honest saying Santa Claus is just like St Nicholas is like saying Snoop Dogg is just like Martin Luther King because they're both black and talk about race and money. On the one hand we have big fat well fed Santa who visits all of the world all of the rich developed world and gives presents and well, the richer you are the more extravagant your presents are going to be. St Nicholas on the other hand used his entire inheritance to help the poor, sick, and children in need. He gave in secret, expecting nothing in return. He saved young women from slavery, protected sailors, spared innocents from execution, provided grain in a famine and rescued a kidnapped boy. Unlike fat jolly Santa, St Nicholas often looked as grumpy as all get out.


I'm going to guess that in a life given that was given to serving the poor, he didn't suffer fools gladly. Most famously at the council of Nicea he got so irritated by Arius rambling on about how he didn't like the idea of the trinity St Nicholas slapped him in the face. Tell Nicholas his memory had been usurped by a fat man handing out presents to the wealthiest quarter of the world and I reckon there'd be fireworks. So if you want honour the legend of St Nicholas find yourself a Santa and slap them in the face or buy something from TEAR's gift catalogue.

This post was inspired by / stolen from this post by Peter Enns

Monday, December 03, 2012

A Review Of "The Indie Hymnal" By Greg Attwell

This Review first appeared in the October Edition of The Uniting Church Newspaper Revive. I forgot to post it the Blog until now.
---

If you’ve ever wondered what it might sound like if Sufan Stevens (hipster singer song writer) took over the music at church and reinterpreted some old hymns, then this album is worth checking out. The title is a nod to the laid back acoustic style of musicians like Stevens, Iron and Wine or Angus and Julia Stone (so, despite the name “Indie” it’s the kind of music a grandmother would be happy to hear). 

The album is sumptuously recorded almost exclusively with acoustic instruments. There are no drums or percussion, adding to the soft relaxed feel. If you’re a church musician, Indie Hymnal is a great resource.

As a listening album, however, it’s probably not one I will be returning to regularly. The vocal and musical performance is just a bit too clinical. There are no guitars strummed louder than they should be and the vocals communicate a sense of reverence for the material but lack the sense of conviction or struggle you might hear in a David Bazan rendition.

Saturday, December 01, 2012

Rethinking "The Fall"

The usual retelling of the Genesis 3 story goes something like this... God made the world, told Adam and Eve not to eat from the tree of knowledge and they did. God banishes them forever because... well we don't get an exact answer why but often the subtext I hear, when the story is retold, is that Adam and Eve are kicked out because God (like a horrible headmaster) likes to have petty rules and if you break just one then that's it, busted for life. Nadia Bolz-Weber asks what if Adam and Eve went to God and said we've stuffed up and we're sorry. Would God have still said that's it, you're out forever? I can't help but think that just doesn't sit right. Maybe the break with God was not because of Adam and Eve's inability to keep a somewhat arbitrary rule but because they were unable to be honest with God and take responsibility about what happened. Like a five year old with chocolate all over their face they insisted someone else did it. Relationships survive mistakes, stuff ups and broken promises all the time. What they do not survive is dishonesty. We have all felt that sense of shame that stops us telling the whole truth. There can be overwhelming urge to lie about a situation rather than tell the truth so we can appear to be (like God) perfect. But when we do lie, no matter how well we do it we feel some sense of shame. Maybe this is why Adam and Eve felt exposed (naked) and ashamed.

Thursday, November 29, 2012

The Rules About Rules

I was listening to John Cleary's Sunday night religious radio show today, and there was a discussion about religion and sex, following the (UK)Anglican churches decision on women bishops. Lots was being said about various issues then Dr. Michael Horsburgh said this...

"If you want to understand a rule you have to look for the evil that it is expected to redress. So, people see something wrong, they say we need a law against it, so we are to create a rule and you can understand a law, whether we agree with it or not, you can understand the law in the context of the evil it seeks to redress. But, laws and rules last longer than the evils. So some reach their use by date that's why that's why it's actually very important that we understand what the context were originally behind the kinds of rules that we've inherited the because in a new context those rules may not be particularly useful." Dr. Michael Horsburgh

I thought it was genius, could easily be applied to so many church / Xn rules so I had to repost it.

Friday, November 02, 2012

Why I Feel Uncomfortable Thanking The "Traditional Owners"

Imagine if someone's grandparents stole a Stradivarius violin off my grandparents. They then became a famous musician, partly because of the unique sound of the stolen violin. Then imagine that each time they played a concert with that violin they thanked me, because I was the "traditional owner" of the violin.

If that happened to me I'd feel ripped off, patronised and pretty friggin' angry. Particularly if they were living a life of rock star luxury and I was living in poverty.

Thursday, November 01, 2012

I Think I Need To Stop Going To Church

The church I'm hanging out with is doing a series where we get to think about what our "frontline" is? That is where we might already be "missionaries"? Or, who we can tell the gospel too? To be honest I'm always nervous about these sorts of things as they can often water down Xy to some kind of religious pyramid selling scheme. Where sermons become rallying cries for sales teams.

None the less, I have a faith that has transformed my life for the better and one that I believe is worth sharing with the people I know and love. I reflected about the people I connect with on a regular basis in particular my closest friends. Serendipitously two of them (both not Xn) and I had a long conversation about Xy. During the conversation it became brutally obvious that they will never come to church. (This is probably also true of many of the other people I know).

Thinking about this I remembered an old friend becoming Xn, at the time she only knew me and one other Xn person. She started going to church and about four weeks later chucked church in and later after moving to a different part of the state everything else kind of faded away. Jesus was great but she couldn't square Jesus with the way church folk did life and the values they lived. Church was and still is the only way I knew to give some sort of form to Xn discipleship.

I cannot help but feel that Church has become an albatross to mission. Unless I abandon church and work out some other way of being Xn, some way of living and growing as a person of faith rooted in the long history of the faith that I can then hand on to others, then my friends and many others I know will never consider becoming Xn.

To be honest right now I have no idea why I even go to church. I get nothing out of it and I give nothing to it.

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Playing "My Way" At Funerals A Sign Of Hyper-Individualism Or Loneliness.

Yet another A Churchless Faith post addressing topical issues way too long after they have happened. I have a family that comes first blog comes way down the list. Sorry. Anyway...

A couple of weeks ago the Sydney Anglican Arch Bishop was in the news speaking out against the playing of Frank Sinatra's "My Way" at funerals and the way he felt that it embodied a culture of individualism. My first thought was that I don't think he understands why people would want to play this song at a funeral. I was further surprised when I heard a large panel of people on Radio National discussion generally agree with Peter Jensen's sentiments.

I do not think playing "My Way" at a funeral comes about as either a celebration of or a cause of individualism. Rather, it is a symptom of the loneliness and isolation that people experience.

For better or worse gone are the days of extended family support, inheriting a trade from your father, a high school or university qualification guaranteeing long term stable employment, marriage as a life long commitment, your neighbours not only people who lived beside you but also worked played and went to school with you.

Certainly all of the above has a dark side. But theses things have gone leaving many people isolated and lonely. I believe many people play "My Way" simply because there was not a community with whom they could do it "Our Way". I suspect that for many "My Way" is more of a celebration of survival rather than individualism.



Tuesday, October 30, 2012

Wiping The Dust Off Our Feet Means Ignore People Who Don't Like You. Huh?

This week I heard a church talk where it was suggested that we should “wipe the dust off our feet” or forget about or ignore those neighbours who don't like you. The idea comes from Luke 9:5 (and similar passages) “Wherever they do not welcome you, as you are leaving that town shake the dust off your feet as a testimony against them”

I've got two kinds of neighbours those who hide behind their roller doors (I could sit next to them on the train and never know) and those whose kids play at my house. This second group of neighbours are hard drinking footy loving pot smoking folk with “F*** off we're full” stickers on their car. That's not to say they are not nice people but we don't have any natural points of connection. I’m pretty sure they like having us as neighbours, appreciate the occasional free carton of eggs but that's it. We're never going to be drinking bourbon together listening to ACDC and talking cars and footy.

By the logic of the talk these are the sorts of people I should be "wiping the dust of my feet off" at because, as the speaker said, they aren't "people of peace". That just doesn't seem right to me. It’d mean wiping my feet of my entire suburb. Each night I thank God that despite what I do, how much I scream “God where are you? And, why don’t you do something” that God has not wiped the dust off God’s sandals and decided to walk away from me. If God does that for me and God asks me to be God’s ambassador I’m not sure I can leave these people and metaphorically shake the dust off my feet as a testimony against them.

A Reflection On "The Authority Of Scripture"

I recently had a conversation with an old friend on Facebook about wifely submission. I was trying to ask him how would explain wifely submission to a non Xn person or what the intrinsic benefits of being a submissive wife are. He kept going back to "this is what I think Ephesians 5 is saying". The exchange probably says more about my inability to communicate via social networks than it does about my friends ability to understand what I was trying to ask. Which was what are the benefits to following this idea aside from "it's in the Bible".

None the less, it got me think about how "The Authority Of Scripture" functions. For more evangelically minded people this means once you've decided to follow Jesus you decide to follow everything in the Bible too. For more liberally minded people reason and tradition may play a bigger role and you kind of get a two against one get out of jail free card if they both go against something they believe is being said in the Bible.

I'm wondering if, for me, the Bible has authority because of what it says rather than because of what it is. That is the Bible, for me, is more like Martin Luther King rather than the Pope. If you don't like what the Pope says, and you have a "what the Pope says goes" kind of Catholicism, you're just stuck with what ever has been decreed. MLK on the other hand only maintained authority when what he said continued to ring true in some sense.

If I found something MLK said that sounded offensive or uncharacteristic. I would neither believe it nor dismiss that one thing or everything that he ever said. I'd ask
1) Is this really what he said? Was it transcribed incorrectly?
2) What was the context he was talking in? Was he talking metaphorically or sarcastically rather than literally?
3) Is it something he later went on to regret saying?
4) If I don't get a satisfactory answer I'll mentally file it away in the don't quite understand what's going on here corner of my brain.

If I'm honest with myself I suspect this is exactly how I've treated the Bible. I believe God is loving, Jesus is God's demonstration to us of what God is like, and the Bible is our window to understanding that more fully.

If I find something in the Bible that seems to go against this I have to ask.  Do I change my idea of what or who God is or do I wrestle with the text until I understand it differently. I tend to ask these questions of myself.

1) Is this really what was said in the original text? Is how I understand this today how the original hearers / reader would have understood it?
2) What was the context the author was writing in? Was the author talking in some other form rather than literally?
3) Is it something (particularly if it's something from the Hebrew Bible) something that the prophets, Jesus or a New Testament writer would challenge?
4) If I don't get a satisfactory answer I'll mentally file it away in the don't quite understand what's going on here corner of my brain.

Over my life at different times I have filed away the issues of gender roles, sexuality and Joshua's conquest (to name but a few) and then revisited them when I found a satisfactory understanding of them. There are still things filed away in the doesn't make sense yet compartment in my brain. Maybe I'll get to then maybe I won't.

Either way I won't be throwing away the bible or submitting to any one's particular understanding of what the Bible means.

Friday, October 05, 2012

Understanding The John 14:6 Trump Text

The dudes at Homebrewed Christianity are about to do a podcast on John 14:6. The "I am the way the truth and the life" text. This passage often gets used against more peace love and mung bean Xns when they are doing their "God love everyone man" thing. Kind of like a trump card to discount of God being overly inclusive. When someone pulls this trump card what they usually mean is not "Jesus is the way the truth and the life" but, if you haven't said a prayer to invite Jesus into your heart and then followed that up by attending a church whose theology roughly coincides with that big selling books at that persons favourite cheesy Xn bookshop, then you are not in with God.

Here are my thoughts on this verse. Following Jesus would have been theologically confusing for the disciples. Tax collectors and prostitutes were in but the Pharisees were out. The first were made last and the last, first. In Jesus' Sheep an Goats parable even those who call Jesus lord don't even get in.

At the beginning of John 14 Jesus announces that he will be leaving the disciples and they want some assurance. In John 14:6 Jesus tells them that he is the gate keeper it is he who decides who is in and out. There is no magic prayer to get Jesus in your heart. There is no ritual or sacrifice to be made to make sure that you are in with God, just the assurance that Jesus is the way and that he will continue to declare the tax collector, the prostitute and people like the sheep in the sheep and goats parable who don't even know Jesus as part of the kingdom of God.

So, yes I fully embrace John 14:6. But, any theological ideas that come from what we think John 14:6 means must concur with Matthew 25:31-46 (the sheep and the goats parable) and not from our own desire to be the gatekeepers of who is in and out with God. That we are not that gate keep is precisely what we learn in both passages.

Sunday, September 30, 2012

Experiencing God Or Not

This week I read a post by theologian Tony Jones where he expresses a profound lack of experiencing or hearing from God. I also heard the story of someone on their death bed who had a profound experience of God. I feel an urge to embrace and affirm both experiences. I know you are supposed to fall down on one side or the other as to what should be the "normal" Xn experience but right now I'm trying to formulate something that embraces both experiences. Something that does not say that one is correct and the other means either you're not really a Xn or you are somewhat delusional. 

Personally I can relate most with the silent nothing (Tony Jones) experience of God. Perhaps other people have a different make up. An imaginative (not imaginary) make up where they are able to experience the reality of God through a far more imaginative or mystical experience. This is not to say the experience is not real just because it might not be able to be recorded on a video camera. Like the often very visceral experience of falling in love the revelation of God may also be very real. But for those of us with a different make up, it doesn't make our experience less real (perhaps like the love of a couple who've stuck at loving each other decades after the giddy excitement of first meeting has died down). For people like me it only seems less real or less "normal" if I have enough people telling me this is not the normal Xn experience or that I'm missing out. For people who experience God differently perhaps it's all about what sort of a person they are and how they experience the world rather than that God has arbitrarily chosen to speak to some people in one way and other people in another. 

To be honest I love how I experience life, love and God in all it's complex vagueness and I wouldn't change it for the world.