As I
previously posted I had a bit of a misunderstanding with Father Bob
For those of you new to this blog here is some background:
1) I call myself a Christian (Xn for short in this blog). But that probably doesn’t mean what you think it means. See possibly
here, perhaps
here and maybe
here for example.
2) I categorically don’t believe that helping people in anyway should be used as a vehicle for telling people what you believe. I believe that helping the poor is in and of itself is what Xns are called to do (see Matt 25:34-36 if you’re the kind of person who likes to look at those kind of things. Also I lampooned how I think many Xns wish this verse would read
here)
3) I really like Father Bob and in a
previous post I described as my new hero.
I think there were basically three comments I made that Father Bob took the wrong way. I have outlined what I said what I think Father Bob thought I meant and what I meant but didn’t explain to well.
Problem comment 1
Really enjoy the questions to Bob about how he thinks we might solve some of the problems in the world (and how his faith informs that)?
When reading this I think Father Bob thought I was saying that faith is the base from which we do street work.
What I think: Ok this might be a bit lengthy. Firstly my aim in life above anything else is to pursue truth. What is true and what is right. So I want to pursue what is right about God and what is not. What is right about how we live and what is not (granted that to some extent this maybe relative Eg: on one hand “the white stripes” may or may not be a great band but on the other hand murder is wrong). At the moment with 33 years of searching I hold the beliefs that I currently hold (this blog representing a small slice of some of those beliefs) as a result of this ongoing search for truth about God and life. I am always wanting to have these beliefs challenged because I think that is the only way I will grow as a person. What’s more, I want to have my beliefs and ideas challenged by people I respect. So this is why I want to know what motivates Father Bob (someone who I respect). Including how is faith motivates him to do what he does and why I don’t really want to know what Slobodan Milošević (someone I don’t respect) thinks about treating other people.
Problem comment 2
“whoever is not against you is for you” ;).
Listening to Podcast 19 I think Father Bob thought I was saying that he (and others) should work with preachy type Xns because they are not against the work he is doing
What I think: This comment was a quote of Jesus from the book of Luke. Luke 9:50 to be exact. I stupidly assumed that Bob would instantly spot it as such. None the less Jesus says this when the disciples want Jesus to tell off some people who are casting out demons in his name. Now I know that’s not something you see on your average street corner today but it was certainly something a bit more common in Jesus day when, I suspect there were a few more unknowns about how things worked. (An example might be the disciples and a crowd mistaking what we all now would recognise as an epileptic fit as (see Mark 9:17-29)). So, perhaps rather than reading it as casting out a demon for the sake of this argument it’s probably sufficient enough to say that there was someone who was doing something good to help people and he was not part of the group of the disciples (the Xn religious establishment if you like). My reading is that by Jesus saying “whoever is not against you is for you” he is saying it doesn’t matter if you are part of the right religion or group or not. It is what you do that is most important. In fact in Matt 25:37-40 the bit straight after the passage I referred to earlier we have Jesus welcoming people into the kingdom of heaven who have no Xn religious allegiance what so ever. They have only done what is right – help the poor. So I’d say anyone does this kind of stuff it makes them in with God, and those people who ignore this kind of stuff to do say evangelism are not in with God. So with this in mind I’d say that to be preachy is to not be Xn. In podcast 19 Father Bob said that he would tell people what he believed if he had a gun to his head. I think that this is a great image for what I think about telling people what you believe. That is, I think I might have something worth believing in and therefore worth sharing with others only if what I believe causes me to act in such a positive way that people around me, metaphorically, hold a gun to my head and ask me what I believe. What is more I’d only share it when they ask in that gun to the head style. That is if someone asks me why I helpt someone I wouldn’t take it as a licence to launch into a diatribe about what I believe, because I know that’s not what they want. I might answer in the same way that I’d answer a friend at school asking me if I liked a girl I had a crush on at school. If I felt I trusted them I’d give them little bits at a time until they stopped asking. Anything less than that and I’m an annoying Amway salesman selling ice to Eskimo’s.
Problem comment 3
many of the helping agencies are faith based to some extent.
I think father Bob may have seen this as a further endorsement of the idea that faith comes first and then helping.
What I think: The fact that many of the helping agencies are faith based is something important to look at. What people believe has a big impact on how they act. For example according to the
National Church Life Survey church going people tend to do more volunteering than non church going people. What the exact motivation for this is is another question. Belief affecting action doesn’t just go for church going people others might help because they won’t someone to change the way they live (eg: stop using a drug that is debilitating them). We all have motivations for what we do and I think that it is important we are fully open and honest about this. We need to be to work out if we will actually be a help to people. For example I have met people who have said their motivation for doing street work is to meet people in need and help them. This all sounds well meaning but often I have seen them meet a drug addict who’s addiction is causing themselves a lot of damage, they have correctly identified the drug addiction as the cause of the problems but the addict has rejected their help and the helper walks away feeling like the exercise was a waste of time. (A further investigation of the why this person wanted to help might have revealed that really they just wanted people to heed their advice) I say this to illustrate that all people have a motivation to do what they do and often it comes from a great place but we need to be aware of what that is, as often what people want and need is not what we were hoping to give them. This is also something that people of any faith need to look at particularly for those in more conservative or evangelical Xn churches as I think that declining numbers in churches has led to a push to preach the message at every opportunity (so to speak). Many have been turned away precisely because of this. Most people don’t want to listen to let alone become an Amway salesperson no matter how much they enjoy the product. I have met many people in these kind of churches who have good hearts and who I think have been mislead as too what living like a Xn looks like. I would love for people like this to hear a bit of how Father Bob’s faith informs how he lives, and hence the reason for asking Father Bob how his faith informs what he does. I think this would lead to not only and most importantly more people loving other people but would actually lead to more people being interested in what these people believe.
In conclusion I don’t want to have an agenda to push I want to have truth to seek. I want to learn from all who I can. I am happy to tell other people what I know, knowing all the time that I will probably learn more from them than they from me.
Also please note the following...
1) Any of the comments I have made on this and other blogs were purely my own views and not in anyway representative of the views of the organisation Drug ARM.
2) The link on the Father Bob blog is to the head office in Queensland for whom I do not work.
I have asked for the reference to Drug ARM to be removed from the Father Bob Blog but it hasn't been.
I will post again soon particularly after having resolved not to post comments on other people’s blogs and in e-groups for a while.
Peace and Grace to you all.